Transparency is a buzzword in the coffee world. Roasteries promote it, labels promise it, and consumers demand it, often without knowing exactly what it means. It is frequently reduced to a single number: the FOB price. Yet a price alone, divorced from its context, says much and simultaneously nothing. And yet transparency is more important today than ever before. It is not a marketing tool but must be a fundamental approach for the entire value chain.
Almost all of us drink coffee, but almost none of us have ever been on a coffee farm. That is not necessary to appreciate coffee either. Similarly, it is not necessary to understand how coffee is made if the coffee's story is told well. But for this story to be told, transparency is needed. The term has been omnipresent since the mid-2010s, is often used, but perhaps not always interpreted the same way.
The Misunderstanding: What We Mean When We Talk About Transparency
What is Transparency?
The term "transparency in the coffee chain" refers to how openly and comprehensibly information about the coffee's journey is made available – from farm to cup. It is about shedding light on every single step of this complex supply chain.

Information exists, but it is not always shared
In short, transparency means telling the entire story of coffee openly. Not just where it comes from, but also under what conditions it was grown, at what price, and with what impact on people and the environment. It goes beyond labels and attempts to create a deeper connection from the beginning to the end of the coffee chain.
Coffee trade was not transparent for centuries. Where transparency is lacking, accountability is also lacking. Coffee was a classic colonial product, produced using slave labor. Well into the 20th century, people were forced into coffee production. And to this day, people in certain regions produce coffee due to lack of alternatives and are trapped in dependent structures. But there is another way: when work is done transparently and communicated openly.
Is There Greater Demand for Transparently Traded Coffee?
Not directly.
There is a clear upward trend for Fairtrade coffees. In Germany, sales rose by 13% in 2024 and achieved a market share of 5.3%. In Switzerland, 18% of all sold coffee carries the Fairtrade label, and sales increased by 22% in 2024.
From the Fairtrade Impact Report 2024/25
However, the latest study by the DKV shows: A clear majority of respondents has little interest in the precise details of coffee production. Taste, strength, and price continue to dominate general purchasing behavior. Only 42% of test subjects found "sustainable production" important to very important, while 67% found price important.
Perhaps the topic of transparency is more relevant to the specialty coffee and small roastery market, as the prevailing notion often is: Small roasteries are automatically more transparent, quality coffee is inherently more sustainable, and naming the exact origin creates sufficient closeness and trust.
I would not confirm any of these three ideas, however.
The size and quality focus of a roastery play no role in how transparently someone operates. Naming the exact origin is nowadays merely a communication decision – the information is available at most roasteries. The equation "high quality = high sustainability" does not add up either.
I have tasted qualitatively fantastic coffees from farms that massively use glyphosate and neglect workers' rights. And I have tasted really bad coffee from farms that could be a compass for many others in terms of sustainable coffee production.
Is Transparency Sustainable? Untangling the Concepts
It is already clear up to this point: the concept of transparency becomes mixed up with ideas of sustainable production, fair payment, and good partnerships. This overloads the term and makes it imprecise.
Transparency is not a concept, but an instrument to achieve the stated goals at all. Just as a solar panel is an instrument for making a lightbulb shine, transparency enables us to see things. Nothing more. Companies that use transparency as a tool can go far beyond just seeing and, with clear sight, initiate change.

A new way of seeing is called for. La Capilla, Coscomatepec, Mexico
A transparent approach creates the foundation for being able to act more sustainably at all. It is the foundation for trust, long-term relationships, and authenticity. And that is precisely why transparency is more important today than ever: it is the foundation for good and stable relationships at every intersection of the chain.
How the Market Enforces Transparency: The Changing Price
Coffee is always traded because it is a cash crop. An agricultural culture that is planted for sale or export purposes and thus to generate profit – meaning cash (money) through the crop (cultivated crop).
The way coffee is sold and bought, thus traded, differs in who negotiates with whom and on what basis a price is determined. A large cooperative in Brazil does not seek small roasteries as buyers who only purchase sacks and not containers, while a large trader does not include micro-producers in its portfolio for reasons of granularity.
The C-Price is always part of a price negotiation between buyer and seller. When in autumn 2024 the green coffee price reached one all-time high after another, the world became aware that even specialty roasteries are affected by this C-Price. It is not the case that quality-oriented roasteries are immune to it; on the contrary: everyone is in the same boat. And that is a good thing.
However, the C-Price is not the cost-reflective price for green coffee. It reflects supply and demand, which is determined by actual coffee availability, volume estimates, and speculation.
The C-Price is public, and coffee producers often know its smallest fluctuations much better than many roasteries. Because: when the price goes up, producers wait with selling. When it goes back down, they tend to sell.
A New Negotiation Culture Through High Prices
At the latest with higher coffee prices, many buyers had to engage even more with the C-Price. It became clear that no one acts independently of it, regardless of how stable a relationship with coffee producers is. And that is why the C-Price moved so strongly to the center of negotiations that a new understanding of prices emerged.
For years, especially specialty roasteries have said that the C-Price is far too low for producers to live on. Now it is high, and that confronts roasteries with a challenge, as they must raise prices, which fuels concerns about customers leaving.
So in recent months, I observed how many buyers and sellers discussed prices and individual cents more intensively than ever before. Roasteries (buyers) had to calculate how much they need to adjust prices upward, sellers (traders, producers, cooperatives) have argued how high local prices are, how small their margin represents, and how high the credit risk is.
Exchange of information in both directions. Apas visiting us in Basel
The high C-Price has thus led to more transparency in price setting. Sellers and buyers have communicated their figures as openly as never before. And this knowledge now exists. I am convinced that we as an industry will not fall back into a pre-2024 era because the strong price pressure brought with it a knowledge surge that is now definitive. Price negotiations will be more transparent from now on.
Still Far From Transparent Enough: Moving Toward Cost-Reflective Pricing
"Open book" was the motto for many buyers in recent months, and they shared their figures with sellers. That was unimaginable just a few months ago. The concerns of buyers forced them to communicate more transparently. And yet the cost-reflective price remains untouched. The selling price that accounts for all production costs, including so-called externalized costs such as environmental impacts.
Homemade organic fertilizer at Apas in Brazil
That must be the next step to achieve truly transparent pricing. This requires capturing what constitutes a good income for producers. The "good income" cannot be determined by roasteries or a C-Price.
In a perfect world, producers would decide what they need, but the C-Price remains the reference. However, to gain a more realistic understanding of how to contextualize the C-Price, tools like the Living Income Benchmark from Fairtrade help. It can help obtain contextualized figures on what plausible wages in certain regions of the world could be. Furthermore, knowledge of production costs, a margin, plus external costs would be needed to calculate a comprehensive price for green coffee.
This is a long journey, and it requires more transparency for all stakeholders in the coffee chain to answer these questions. Transparency is essential for proper price formation. Beyond that, we must ask ourselves:
who actually benefits from transparency?
For Whom Is Transparency Decisive? Different Perspectives
Of course, there are limits to transparency.
When we talk about transparency in the coffee chain, we imply trading practices, prices paid, cultivation methods, perhaps working conditions and environmental impacts. Most often, these are topics that concern cultivation.
Roasteries that demand much transparency from traders and producers are invited to show the same amount of transparency themselves. As a principle, this could apply:
The degree of transparency I demand from you, I will also give to you.
And thus one sets one's own limits on transparency, because there may be topics one does not like to discuss. Thus, those of a kind find each other in the chain.
What Do Individual Chain Actors Gain From Transparency?
Let's assume that the greatest possible degree of transparency is applied to a particular coffee chain, everyone feels comfortable with it, and information exchange happens in both directions – from seed to cup and from cup to seed. Often there is information asymmetry. But if that is broken down, there are opportunities for everyone involved.
When information asymmetry is broken down, there are opportunities for all:
Producers:
- Empowerment through knowledge about the value of their product and the opportunity to negotiate fair prices beyond production costs.
- Access to direct, long-term partnerships that enable stability and investment in sustainable cultivation methods.
- Improvement of working conditions and fair wages for farm workers, who are often underpaid.
Green Coffee Importers:
- Their important role as bridge builders between producers and roasters, managing logistics and quality assurance.
- The opportunity to strengthen trust throughout the entire chain through their own transparency (e.g., regarding their margins and services).
- Risk management through detailed knowledge of origin and production conditions.
Coffee Roasters:
- Building a strong brand and credibility through authentic stories and traceable origins.
- Improving purchasing strategies through deeper insights into the cost structures of producers and optimizing the supply chain.
- Differentiation in competition and attracting a conscious customer base that values ethical consumption.
Customers:
- The ability to make informed purchasing decisions that align with their personal values (e.g., environmental protection, social justice).
- Understanding the "true price" of coffee, which reflects the social and ecological costs along the value chain ("True Pricing").
- Appreciation of the product and the work behind every cup of coffee through detailed origin information.
Interpreting Transparency Correctly. The Need for Contextual Knowledge
When comparing two 87-point coffees, one from Kenya and one from Brazil, you know that these 87 points taste different. Coffees from Kenya and Brazil taste fundamentally different but can have high ratings on individual taste attributes and thus reach 87 points.
Same score, different reason, we often say at tastings.
But if I only communicated the 87 points without the context of origin, variety, processing, etc., then that tells me the coffee is probably very good. But I still do not know how it tastes, what purpose it might suit, and who else might like it.
Likewise, bare numbers and facts are not helpful in the transparency debate. An FOB price viewed in isolation, the type of harvest and processing, ownership structures in the chain – all information that says little without context. Two examples of this:

Don Roque produces high-quality coffee; yield per hectare is under 1 ton
High Price for Good Coffee:
Micro-producers in the mountain region of Oaxaca, Mexico, are often entirely dependent on their small harvest. This makes the coffee exclusive and more expensive. A higher price is necessary here for their survival and is determined by scarcity, not solely by quality in the cup.
Affordable Price for Excellent Coffee:
An excellent lot from a Colombian producer with over 100 hectares of land was rated qualitatively higher but was priced identically to the Oaxaca coffee. Due to size, efficiency, and modern fermentation in large tanks, the coffee could be produced more cheaply.
The prices were identical but had no direct relation to sensory qualities; instead, they related to economies of scale and cultivation methods. Without context, a price is just a number.
What Do Price Statements Like FOB Really Say?
Initiatives like "The Pledge" invited roasteries in 2018 to share FOB prices to bring transparency to price setting. That was an important step in the right direction, so that a small shock went through the specialty world. Many roasteries continue to share their purchase prices on an FOB basis.
"FOB is just the beginning," states the 2019 vision. Only when all prices in the coffee chain become transparent does it provide the opportunity to calculate a Living Income Price or even a cost-reflective price.
The FOB price (free on board) means that the exporter bears all costs up to loading onto the ship. Once the coffee is on the ship, subsequent costs go to the import side. An exporter can, but does not have to be, the producer themselves.
Costs before and after this point are incurred, which are reflected in different pricing models:
Payment for Pickers
Does not appear in classical pricing models but is factored into the farmgate price. There is a reference point for this, the "Living Wage" approach, which differs from "Living Income": While "living wage" represents an employment relationship, "living income" is the reference for independent earnings. The "living wage" approach therefore serves to determine payment for pickers; for farm owners, it is "living income".
Ex-Farmgate
The price a producer receives for coffee directly from the farm.
FOT (Free on Truck)
The price after the coffee has been transported from the dry mill to the port and changes ownership there.
FOB (Free on Board)
The price when the coffee is loaded onto the ship. The exporter bears all costs up to this point.
DDP (Delivered Duty Paid)
The price for coffee when it arrives, cleared and taxed, at the threshold of the roastery.
The costs mentioned are so-called Incoterms: definitions that establish who bears which costs and when goods are transferred. Furthermore, Incoterms provide information about whether the goods are forwarded by the buyer or seller.

Every coffee chain has its peculiarities and often never functions identically.
Coffee supply chains are based on Incoterms, which often resemble each other but differ in detail. A few peculiarities can be:
- it is not a single producer but rather they are part of an organization (e.g., cooperative)
- individual producers typically do not own a dry mill, the facility where coffee is made export-ready
- the dry mill service can be purchased, or the dry mill buys the coffee and exports it
- cooperatives or exporters (traders) typically own dry mills
- the exporter always needs a counterpart, the importer, who then buys the coffee. These can be subsidiaries or independent companies.
Therefore, the questions:
What does the FOB price really say?
Without context, not much.
The basic idea of FOB communication is that eventually you have enough transparency to calculate the Living Income. But neither the FOB price nor the ex-farmgate price is sufficient for that. It requires more precise calculations that engage with individual living conditions on site.
The FOB price, without context, is simply a number. And just because a roastery communicates this price does not mean it can be assumed to be a good price for producers.
I repeatedly see roasteries stating the FOB price with the additional information that the paid price is x times the C-Price (the exchange reference price). I believe this means two things:
- the willingness to communicate transparently, which is necessary and commendable
- the intention to pursue different communication, which is incomplete if not contextualized
Context is king – as long as the FOB price stands alone, it does not mean much. Only the collection of additional data points provides a more complete picture of how the coffee was traded.
An FOB price of 10 USD per pound of green coffee seems high. But if the ex-farmgate price was only 5 USD, that means the costs for processing, logistics, and export margin have doubled the price – an enormous markup. Just because a roastery communicates the FOB price is no guarantee of a fair price for producers.
Here are our FOB prices, which we pay for green coffees.
Is Transparent Also Fair?
As mentioned at the beginning, transparency is an instrument that helps us understand at all what happens in a long trading chain. Where a product is charged with monetary and ideological values, whose contribution in the chain improves the product, and what we can further learn from it.
Transparency is necessary, but standing alone, it is not an explanation for deeper understanding of a commodity chain. Nor is transparent information without subsequent action a guarantee of fairness.
An ethical dilemma can emerge when we find ourselves in information asymmetry; when one part of the coffee chain knows more about the market and more about the other part than vice versa. The goal should therefore be that the benefits of transparency also reach the producers and that solutions can be worked on together.
The Future of Transparency
Coffee companies that are accountable to third parties, e.g., a label organization like Fairtrade or Rainforest Alliance, or even shareholders, must per se work more transparently than many smaller companies and often demonstrate a higher degree of precision.
Whether this information is then also shared with customers and producers is another story. However, the practice of learning more about one's own chain has long been conducted, especially at larger companies. Who ultimately benefits from this remains unclear.
For change to happen at all, transparency is needed across entire supply chains. Above all, however, it requires the self-understanding of how we, as companies, individuals, and institutions, relate to transparency. If it represents the guardrails for our actions, we think it in both directions ("I share as much as I ask"), and we see it as a creative means for change processes, then it is a powerful tool for a sustainable coffee chain.
















