Two entry-level espresso grinders, both called Fred: the Lelit PL043MMI for approximately 185 euros and the Lelit PL044MMT for approximately 235 euros. We have tested both extensively and, as always, purchased them ourselves. And both show the same result, just packaged differently.
The Freds ran in the most affordable comparison group of the first set of our espresso grinder test series in the range between 150 and 250 euros. At that time, we compared 24 grinders directly, and since then over 100 have passed through our lab. How we measure is explained in the espresso grinder test protocol. You can find all our Lelit tests bundled on the overview page Lelit at a glance.
What sets the two Freds apart
Less than the price difference suggests. The grinding mechanism is the same conical burr in both grinders. The PL044MMT is larger and has programmable timing dosing, while the PL043MMI has the transmission visibly exposed, and the larger one has everything covered.
Both are built from bent sheet metal, and you can tell. Lelit is a machine builder, not a grinder builder. When you bend chromium steel yourself, you take a grinding mechanism and wrap a chromium steel casing around it. This is not poor workmanship, but it is not the kind that brings joy either.
The bean hopper holds about 250 grams and has no slider. In theory, you can remove it, but in practice it means: empty grind, empty out, loosen a black protective cap, unscrew a screw. And then the problem: once you have rotated the hopper, the grind setting scale on the front no longer matches if you haven't marked where you were before. These grinders are not built for daily bean switching.
Noise level, speed, and a safety mechanism
88.9 decibels with the PL044MMT, 87.5 decibels with the PL043MMI. Both are loud. The motor actually sounds like a motorcycle when you adjust it.
They are also slow. 14.3 grams in 10 seconds with the PL044MMT, 15.1 grams with the PL043MMI. So for 18 grams of espresso you need a good twelve seconds. This is at the lower end of the test field.
And then there is a quirk that can really annoy you in everyday use. During our consistency measurement on the PL044MMT, we wanted to grind ten doses in a row. After the third, nothing happened anymore. You press, the grinder does not grind. The user manual explains it: after about three grinding operations of about 10 seconds each, the grinder needs 100 seconds of rest. We suspect thermal protection because the grinder heats up during grinding.
For two espressos in the morning, this is not an issue. But if you want to grind four or five portions in a row for guests, the grinder will eventually stop and won't give you any coffee. Anyone who grinds more than 18 grams at once will hit this lock faster.
The temperature is 38 degrees (PL044MMT) and 37.9 degrees (PL043MMI), with an increase of 0.8 and 0.7 degrees respectively over the measurement series. Both start out warm. We have not found a sensorily clear detectable influence of grinding temperature in our measurement series so far.
Retention and dosing accuracy
4.5 grams retention with the PL044MMT, 5.0 grams with the PL043MMI. Before this grinder test, we would have said: not bad. Today we know there are grinders that are at 3 grams and below. 5 grams is a lot. It is old powder that sits in the grinding mechanism and that you will eventually have to grind through.
In single dosing, the Freds lose 3.7 grams (PL044MMT) and 3.0 grams (PL043MMI). That is too much to meaningfully switch between different coffees while grinding.
We measure the dosing accuracy of the PL044MMT with a standard deviation of 0.48 grams, which corresponds to a variation of around one gram. Combined with the high retention and programming that runs via blink signals, adjusting becomes a test of patience.
The espresso in the cup
This is where it gets unpleasant. Both grinders produce an espresso that is not balanced. The acidity stands sharp and alone, the sweetness is missing, the bitterness has no counterpart. Michel Indelicato, Swiss vice barista champion and course instructor with us, put it this way during the test: "It is not a unity."
However, the problem with the grinders is not the brewing recipe. Even with different recipes, the result in the cup does not come into balance. The coffee has the body of a typical espresso, but it lacks equilibrium. As it cools down, it becomes clearer.
Sensorily, the two Freds are hardly different. One feels a bit softer and more acidity-driven in texture, the other a bit less balanced. These are nuances within a result that is not convincing in either case.
The particle distribution explains why
We made seven particle distribution measurements and evaluated four espresso grindings. The fine portion is at 20.1 percent (PL044MMT) and 21.7 percent (PL043MMI), so in the low range of our 2022 measurements and therefore acceptable. Two other values are the problem.
First, the X50 value, the midpoint of all particles: 359 micrometers with the PL044MMT, 360 with the PL043MMI. This is clearly above 300 and thus in the upper range of the test field.
Second, and this is the actual finding: the width of the main peak. 336 micrometers with the PL044MMT, 349 with the PL043MMI. The best grinder in the test field at that time was at 180 micrometers. These two Lelits thus have the broadest particle distribution of the 24 directly compared grinders.

Particle distribution of the Lelit Fred PL044MMT

Particle distribution of the Lelit Fred PL043MMI
Why it tastes the way it does: extraction happens on each individual particle. The more particles that are the same size, the more uniformly they extract. With a broad distribution, small particles are over-extracted while large ones are not yet done. You get everything in the cup at once, and that is exactly what you taste as a lack of unity.
For comparison, we show the curve of a grinder with a narrower main peak. A narrower main peak typically leads to more balanced shots and more uniform extraction.

Comparison of the Lelit curves with the Eureka XL (X50 303 µm, fine portion 21.6%, coarse peak 239 µm) with the espresso recipe 18 g in, 45 g out in 25 seconds.
What the Freds do well
Two things, and they are not nothing.
First, both grind espresso-fine and even ristretto-fine. This sounds mundane, but for inexpensive espresso grinders it is a basic requirement that not every one meets. The Freds cover our entire espresso range.
Second, the grind setting reproducibility is good. Small changes to the dial change little, you need two or three full turns for a noticeable difference. This makes it easy to find a spot again. Right where the Lelit William PL72 fails in the same category, the Freds are reliable.
And the extraction times are correct: we consistently got precise shots between 23 and 27 seconds. If you want to learn how to dial in espresso, you can practice with these grinders.
Measured values in comparison
| Criterion | Lelit Fred PL044MMT | Lelit Fred PL043MMI |
|---|---|---|
| Price* | approx. 235 € | approx. 185 € |
| Noise level | 88.9 dB | 87.5 dB |
| Retention | 4.5 g | 5.0 g |
| Speed | 14.3 g / 10 s | 15.1 g / 10 s |
| Temperature | 38.0 °C, increase 0.8 ° | 37.9 °C, increase 0.7 ° |
| Dosing consistency | Standard deviation 0.48 g | – |
| Single dosing | 3.7 g loss | 3.0 g loss |
| X50 (espresso) | 359 µm | 360 µm |
| Fine portion | 20.1 % | 21.7 % |
| Main peak width | 336 µm | 349 µm |
| Bean hopper | approx. 250 g, not removable | approx. 250 g, not removable |
| Programmable time dosing | yes | no |
* Prices at the time of testing, not current.

Conclusion on the Lelit Fred PL044MMT and PL043MMI
For the preparation of pure espresso, we cannot recommend the two Freds. The particle distribution is too broad, and that shows directly in the cup. We have measured many grinders in this test, but none where the connection between measured data and taste was so clear.
If you mainly drink cappuccino, latte macchiato, or other milk-based drinks, the assessment changes. Milk is the great equalizer, it brings the sweetness that espresso lacks. In this case, both Freds are usable entry-level grinders, and the PL043MMI at approximately 185 euros is the more honest purchase because the premium for the programmable function of the PL044MMT brings little benefit.
What you cannot do with these grinders: develop yourself sensorially. If you want to find out how different coffees can taste, you will fail with these grinders and look for the error in yourself. This is exactly the experience that participants bring to our courses: everything done right, and yet it does not taste good.
How the Freds compared to the rest of the test field and which grinder won in this price range is in our overview of the best espresso grinders for home, which now includes over 100 tested grinders. You can find a classification of all Lelit devices under Lelit: all tests and models. And if you want to work on recipe and grind setting: preparing espresso.
As always, we purchased both of these grinders ourselves. This test was not commissioned by Lelit.
















